Why Pricing Your Home at Pandemic Boom Levels No Longer Works

If you're thinking about selling your home, one of the most important decisions you’ll make is how to price it. A lot has changed in real estate over the past few years, and while the pandemic market brought some extraordinary highs, today’s conditions are returning to something more balanced and sustainable.

As a seller, it’s crucial to understand that pricing your home based on what happened in 2021 or 2022 could leave your property sitting on the market longer than it should. In today’s environment, homes that are priced right from the start are the ones that get serious offers, generate interest quickly, and close with fewer complications.

The Pandemic Market Was Not the Norm

We all remember the frenzy, multiple offers within days, homes selling well over asking, buyers waiving contingencies just to compete. That period between 2020 and 2022 was an anomaly driven by a perfect storm: record-low interest rates, work-from-home flexibility, and minimal inventory.

During those years, home values in many parts of the country, including here in North County San Diego, skyrocketed. In some cases, sellers saw 30% to 50% appreciation in under two years. It was incredible, but also unsustainable.

Many homeowners are still holding on to the idea that those peak prices are the benchmark. The reality is, they were the exception, not the rule.

What the Market Looks Like Now

The real estate market today is settling into more normalized patterns. While values remain strong, the environment has changed in key ways:

Inventory Is Rising

More homes are hitting the market, giving buyers options and reducing the intense competition we saw just a couple of years ago. Homes are no longer selling out in days. In many cases, they are taking weeks, or even longer, to sell.

Price Growth Has Slowed

We’re still seeing appreciation in some areas, but at a more gradual pace. Gone are the days of dramatic price jumps. Sellers must now focus on strategic pricing rather than riding the wave of rising values.

Buyers Have More Negotiating Power

Buyers today are more selective. They’re not feeling the same pressure to overbid or waive inspections. With higher mortgage rates affecting affordability, many are cautious and expect fair pricing.

Seller Expectations Are Often Misaligned

One of the biggest issues we’re seeing in the current market is sellers overpricing their homes based on outdated comps from the peak of the pandemic. Unfortunately, those numbers no longer reflect what buyers are willing, or able, to pay.

Why Overpricing Hurts Your Sale

When a home is priced too high, a few things tend to happen:

• Fewer showings: Buyers quickly recognize when a property is overpriced. They skip it in favor of better-valued options.
  
  

• Longer time on market: The longer a home sits unsold, the more buyers begin to question what’s wrong with it.
  
  

• Price reductions: These can signal desperation and hurt your negotiating power.
  
  

• Stress and missed opportunities: You may end up chasing the market downward instead of selling quickly and smoothly.
  
  

Ultimately, overpricing often leads to lower final sale prices than if the home had been priced correctly from the beginning.

What a “Normal” Market Looks Like

Let’s be clear: a normal market doesn’t mean a bad market. It simply means that buyers and sellers are operating on more even footing.

In this kind of environment, homes that are well-presented, well-located, and well-priced still sell, and they sell well. But the days of inflated pricing and instant offers are behind us, at least for now.

Real estate is returning to its roots. It’s about strategy, presentation, and timing. For sellers, that means looking at local data, adjusting expectations, and working with an agent who knows how to position your home for success.

How to Price Your Home Right

Here’s how to make sure your pricing strategy works in your favor:

1. Work with a Local Market Expert

National trends are helpful, but real estate is always local. You need someone who understands your neighborhood, buyer behavior, and current demand.

2. Use Today’s Comps, Not Yesterday’s

Look at homes that have sold in the last 30 to 90 days. Those are the numbers that matter—not what your neighbor got in 2021.

3. Factor in Buyer Sensitivity

Interest rates are higher. That impacts how much buyers can afford, even if home prices haven’t dropped dramatically.

4. Be Honest About Your Home’s Condition

Is your home move-in ready? Does it need updates? Today’s buyers are paying close attention to details. Price accordingly.

5. Be Open to Feedback

The market speaks quickly. If your listing isn’t getting traction within the first two weeks, it may be time to reassess.

The Benefits of Getting the Price Right

When you price your home correctly:

• You generate more showings and interest right away
  
  

• You attract serious, qualified buyers.
  
  

• You minimize the need for negotiation or multiple price cuts
  
  

• You create a smoother, faster closing process
  
  

• You maximize your profit potential with less stress
  
  

Pricing isn’t about inflating expectations. It’s about positioning your home to win in the current market, and making sure you don’t leave money on the table by waiting too long or chasing unrealistic numbers.

Final Thoughts

As a trusted real estate advisor in San Diego’s North County coastal communities, I understand how emotional and strategic pricing decisions can be. Your home means something to you, and you want to get the best return possible. That’s where expert guidance comes in.

Today’s market may not look like the pandemic frenzy, but that’s actually a good thing. It’s more stable, more predictable, and more grounded in real value. If you’re thinking about selling, don’t rely on outdated pricing strategies. Let’s create a smart plan that reflects today’s reality and positions your home to stand out.

💬 Ready to Connect?
Let’s talk about your goals, your vision, and how I can help you make your next move with confidence.
📞 (619) 869-1477
🌐www.barbarachamizo.com
 📍 Serving North County Coastal: Del Mar, Solana Beach, Encinitas, Carlsbad, Rancho Santa Fe, and beyond.